Battle of Seattle Doughnuts(or Donuts?)- Top Shop vs Mighty O

Battle of Seattle Doughnuts(or Donuts?)- Top Shop vs Mighty O

Coming from Los Angeles, there seems to be a donut shop on every corner. When I arrived in Seattle in the 90’s, I was shocked how little donut shops there were. My go to was Winchell’s on 45th in Wallingford, but it went out of business and  is  now currently Rancho Bravo Tacos. There are now a few mom and pop doughnut shops, but for the last few years, Top Pot and Mighty O have ruled over the Seattle doughnut landscape. 

 I don’t like cake, pies, cookies or most pastries, but I love donuts. I can’t say i’m a connoisseur of many things, but I definitely feel I can speak to the quality of donuts. 

Let’s get to it. In this corner….  

Mighty-O: Mighty-O’s distinction is that they make their donuts with certified organic ingredients, they contain no cholesterol because there are no chemical preservatives, no animal derived ingredients, no colorings or artificial flavors. 

And in this corner….  

Top Pot: From their website-“With over 40 different types of donuts, Top Pot Doughnuts invites you to join us on our delicious journey of good taste. From our uniquely designed cafés to our hand-roasted coffee and hand-forged gourmet doughnuts, we’re committed to doing things the old fashioned way—beautifully, warmly, and with unfailing attention to details.  Our exceptional quality, vintage aesthetic, and personal customer service offers a fresh take on the old “coffee and doughnuts” routine “

Here’s the tale of the tape: 

• Spelling:  Mighty O Donut vs Top Pot Doughnut.   The first thing you notice is that each spells donut/doughnut differently. 
• Distance from our house: Mighty O: 1.2 miles vs Top Pot: 1.6 miles  

• Locations: 

Mighty O: 4 locations: Ballard, Green Lake, Capitol Hill, Denny Triangle       

Top Pot:23 locations: Including Capitol Hill, Downtown x 3, Wedgewood, Queen Anne, Ballard, South Lake Union, First Hill  

• Price for half dozen( Sprinkles, Maple Bar, Apple Fritter, Glazed, Chocolate, Jelly Filled): 

Mighty O:  $12,99

Top Pot :  $15.39

• Pick Up/Delivery Options: 

Mighty O: Order online and pick up option. Also Amazon Delivery and Caviar Delivery 

Top Pot: No ordering online option. Postmates will deliver.

• Claim to Fame: 

Mighty O: Creating certified organic, non-GMO, cholesterol-free donuts, without chemical preservatives, hydrogenated oils, trans fats, artificial coloring, or flavors. Also cornering the market on supplying local coffee shops-Broadcast, Vivace, Victrola, Vita, Elm Coffee Roasters, Analog Coffee, Zeitgeist. Also Mighty O won a Donut Challenge on Food Network:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NlC8sDrhkDQ

Top Pot: Golden Tate(former : Wide Receiver) breaking into a Bellevue Top Pot because he had a hankering for a maple bar. “They’re irresistible” quoted Mr Tate to the Seattle Times. (link  https://www.seattletimes.com/sports/seahawks/the-great-maple-bar-caper-seahawks-golden-tate-caught-in-3-am-visit-to-top-pot-doughnuts/). Also, Pres Obama got his fill at Top Pot:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1L0k90VXnGo

• Donuts – To be fair we ordered the same 6 donuts from each place to make sure we were comparing apples to apples. We got a maple bar, sprinkle, jelly filled, glazed, apple fritter, and chocolate. We decided to grade each donut on the following criteria.

1) Appetizing/Appearance 

2) Glaze/toppings/frosting 

3) The dough 

4) Filling(when appropriate) 

5) Taste 

Maple Bar

1) Appetizing/Appearance -Top Pot

2) Glaze/toppings/frosting -Top Pot

3) The dough – Mighty O

4) Filling(when appropriate) – N/A 

5) Taste – Top Pot

Winner-Top Pot

 Sprinkles

1) Appetizing/Appearance -Top Pot

2) Glaze/toppings/frosting -Top Pot

3) The dough – Mighty O

4) Filling(when appropriate) – N/A 

5) Taste – Mighty O

Winner- Mighty O. Taste as tie breaker.

Jelly Filled -Sugar on Top Pot, glaze on Mighty

1) Appetizing/Appearance – Mighty O

2) Glaze/toppings/frosting – Mighty O

3) The dough – Mighty O

4) Filling(when appropriate) – Mighty O

5) Taste – Mighty O

Winner – Mighty O

Glazed- Old Fashioned Glazed vs Good O’l Glazed

1) Appetizing/Appearance -Top Pot

2) Glaze/toppings/frosting -Top Pot

3) The dough – Mighty O

4) Filling(when appropriate) – N/A 

5) Taste – Top Pot

Winner-Top Pot

Apple Fritter

1) Appetizing/Appearance -Top Pot

2) Glaze/toppings/frosting -MIghty O

3) The dough – Top Pot

4) Filling(when appropriate) – N/A 

5) Taste – Mighty O

Winner-Mighty O.  Taste as tie breaker.

  Chocolate-Double trouble vs Lots O’ chocolate 

1) Appetizing/Appearance -Top Pot

2) Glaze/toppings/frosting -MIghty O

3) The dough – Mighty O

4) Filling(when appropriate) – N/A 

5) Taste – MIghty O

Winner- Mighty O

Summary:  So by a score of 4 to 2, Mighty O is the Winner!!!  One of the amazing things about Mighty O is that with the use of specific ingredients, you’d think that it would sacrifice taste or texture of the donut, but their donuts are near perfect. We consistently felt that Top Pot donuts look very appetizing both in overall appearance and glaze/toppings. And we also consistently felt that Mighty O won in the texture of the donut and taste. Truthfully you can’t go wrong with either one and when visitors come to town we often get a dozen from either one to show them some local flavor.

Related Articles:

• Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Seattle Coffee Shops
• Morsel vs Biscuit & Bean – The Battle of Seattle’s Best Biscuit Sandwich
• Ezell’s vs Heaven Sent – Battle of Seattle’s Best Fried Chicken
• Battle of the Best Caribbean Sandwiches-Paseo vs Un Bien
• Battle of the Best Seattle Ramen Restaurants